Picture the scenario: You did everything right. Your employee suffered an industrial injury, and in textbook workers’ comp compliance, you promptly brought them back on modified duty.
Then, life happens—an unrelated, non-industrial mishap puts them out on short-term disability (STD). Weeks crawl by. The medical extensions run out, the required doctor’s notes never show up, and every phone call and letter vanishes into a void of total silence. Left with an empty desk and work piling up, you finally process a standard termination for job abandonment.
Then comes the gut punch: a petition arrives from applicant’s counsel alleging you fired them in retaliation under California Labor Code § 132a.
To an employer or claims examiner, this feels absurd. How can separating someone who stopped showing up and refused to answer calls be considered unlawful discrimination? Under California law, the threshold for getting dragged into the fight is shockingly low. Guided by the Supreme Court’s landmark standard in Department of Rehabilitation v. WCAB (Lauher), the applicant only needs to establish a basic prima facie detriment—that they had an industrial injury and suffered an adverse employment action.
However, § 132a is not an all-access pass to permanent employment, nor does having a workers’ comp claim grant an employee to ghost their employer.
The defense’s strongest weapon here is the affirmative defense of “business realities”. The WCAB does not expect a company to hold a vital position open in perpetuity while an employee sits in communication limbo. If you can establish that operational realities demanded that the seat be filled—to stop severe project backlogs, team burnout, or avoid unsustainable overtime—you effectively shatter the applicant’s claim that the discharge was retaliatory.
The catch? Winning this defense lives and dies by your paper trail.
A successful defense requires proving you ran an exhaustive interactive process before pulling the plug. That means sending progressive, trackable warning letters with explicit cure deadlines, keeping pristine logs of outreach attempts, and demonstrating uniform enforcement. If a non-injured worker who vanished without medical paperwork would have been let go under the exact same attendance policy, the causal link to the industrial injury falls apart.
Remember, standard insurance policies cannot shield employers from § 132a penalties or back-pay liability—that check comes straight out of the company’s pocket, unless there are specific contractual clauses. When an employee on modified duty suddenly drops off the radar, treat the separation not as a routine HR exit, but as high-stakes litigation prep: document the business need, exhaust every line of communication, and ensure defense counsel signs off on the paper trail before anyone hits send on that termination letter.
Paria Asadbikli is an associate attorney at Bradford and Barthel’s San Jose Location. When not defending her clients’ interests, Paria serves the legal community as the Scholarship Chair for the Iranian American Bar Association (IABA). She also co-founded BarEssayGrader.com and BarEssayMemo.com, platforms dedicated to assisting law students and bar. If you have questions about workers’ compensation defense issues, feel free to contact Paria at 408.392.8202 or at pasadbikli@bradfordbarthel.com.
Viewing this website does not form an attorney/client relationship between you and Bradford & Barthel, LLP or any of its attorneys. This website is for informational purposes only and does not contain legal advice. Please do not act or refrain from acting based on anything you read on this site. This document is not a substitute for legal advice and may not address every factual scenario. If you have a legal question, we encourage you to contact your favorite Bradford & Barthel, LLP attorney to discuss the legal issues applicable to your unique case. No website is entirely secure, so please be cautious with information provided through the contact form or email. Do not assume confidentiality exists in anything you send through this website or email, until an attorney/client relationship is formed.


