(Note: This is part of a series of blogs by founding partner, Don Barthel, about the finer points of understanding permanent disability and how it is rated in the California workers’ compensation system.)
Permanent disability is often treated as the final arithmetic exercise in a workers’ compensation claim. The medical reports are in, the applicant has reached maximum medical improvement, and someone plugs a few numbers into a rating calculator. The result becomes the settlement target.
That approach is convenient. It can also be expensive.
Decades into defending California workers’ compensation claims, one lesson stands out above the rest: permanent disability is where exposure either gets contained or quietly spirals out of control. A permanent disability rating is not simply a number supplied by a physician. It is the cumulative product of several separate legal and clinical decisions: the medical impairment, the applicable rating method, statutory adjustments, apportionment, the occupational group, the age adjustment, and the final combination of impairments. Each step matters. An unchallenged error early in that chain travels all the way to settlement and turns into a very costly mistake.
Start With the Medical Foundation
The first question is whether the medical report actually constitutes substantial medical evidence capable of supporting the impairment being rated. Has the applicant genuinely reached MMI (Maximum Medical Improvement) / Permanent & Stationary (P&S) status, or are diagnostic modalities and treatment recommendations still open-ended? Does the physician identify the appropriate diagnosis and explain the clinical basis for the impairment? Are the physical examination findings internally consistent with the reported limitations, and do they align with sub-rosa surveillance or activities of daily living?
A diagnosis on an MRI is not automatically a ratable impairment under the AMA Guides (5th Edition). A subjective complaint of pain is not automatically a measurable loss of function. And a physician’s conclusion is not immune from scrutiny merely because it appears in a report bearing an AME or QME letterhead.
You should actively look for unsupported conclusions, non-organic Waddell’s signs, inconsistent range-of-motion measurements, unexplained jumps in impairment, and reliance on subjective complaints without objective clinical corroboration. The goal is not to substitute your medical judgment for the physician’s—it is to spot legal and foundational defects early so defense counsel can seek clarification through targeted supplemental interrogatories or a cross-examination deposition before the report hardens into a formal rating.
Follow the Rating From Beginning to End
Once the medical impairment is established, the rating process must be audited step by step. Confirm that the correct chapter, table, figure, and methodology have been used—for example, ensuring a doctor hasn’t improperly defaulted to the Range of Motion model on a spine claim where the Diagnosis-Related Estimates (DRE) method is strictly mandated, or impermissibly combined gait derangement with focal lower-extremity ratings. Verify the conversion to Whole Person Impairment (WPI). Review any statutory multipliers or adjustments—including the post-2012 1.4 modifier and the statutory bars against derivative psychiatric, sleep, and sexual dysfunction add-ons—and confirm they are legally permissible and supported by the medical findings.
Then examine the remaining rating factors. Does the occupational group reflect the applicant’s actual job duties rather than an inflated job title? Is the age adjustment calculated accurately as of the date of injury? Has apportionment been properly addressed under Labor Code §§ 4663 and 4664, separating causation of disability from causation of injury? Have multiple impairments been combined properly through the Combined Values Chart rather than simply added together?
Do not assume that a rating is correct because it came from a physician, the DEU, applicant’s attorney, or a prior settlement proposal. Everyone makes mistakes. The expensive ones are the mistakes nobody checks.
The Settlement Number Is Not Sacred
A proposed rating should be treated as an opening analytical benchmark, not as an invoice. If the rating appears excessive, incomplete, or internally inconsistent, determine why before setting final reserves or negotiating settlement. Conversely, if a rating appears artificially low, do not assume the defense has stumbled into a bargain. A legally defective rating invites a WCAB judge to reject your settlement or opens the door to future petitions to reopen.
Your mandate is to evaluate the actual, defensible permanent disability exposure—not simply accept the first number presented across the table.
The B&B Advantage
Bradford & Barthel’s AMA Guides Analysis & Rating Department can review the medical reporting and rating methodology, identify potential errors, and help develop a defensible permanent disability evaluation. An independent rating analysis gives you a far more reliable foundation for reserves, deposition prep, and settlement negotiations.
A few minutes of rating review upfront can prevent a lot of explaining later. And nobody enjoys explaining why a claim settled for substantially more than it should have.
Need a PD rating or review?
Bradford & Barthel, LLP — AMA Guides Analysis & Rating Department
Email: ratings@bradfordbarthel.com
Telephone: (916) 569-0790
Don R. Barthel is one of the founding partners of Bradford and Barthel, and is based in the firm’s Sacramento office. He has taken dozens of doctor depositions and analyzed thousands of medical-legal reports in order to correct innumerable errors, including misapplications of the AMA Guides, statutory misunderstandings, and other errors making the underlying medical reporting entirely speculative and unreliable. If you have any questions about workers’ compensation defense issues, please feel free to contact him at 916.569.0790 or via email at dbarthel@bradfordbarthel.com.
Viewing this website does not form an attorney/client relationship between you and Bradford & Barthel, LLP or any of its attorneys. This website is for informational purposes only and does not contain legal advice. Please do not act or refrain from acting based on anything you read on this site. This document is not a substitute for legal advice and may not address every factual scenario. If you have a legal question, we encourage you to contact your favorite Bradford & Barthel, LLP attorney to discuss the legal issues applicable to your unique case. No website is entirely secure, so please be cautious with information provided through the contact form or email. Do not assume confidentiality exists in anything you send through this website or email, until an attorney/client relationship is formed.


